What is a biotic index and why would I want one?

Clever boffins have produced a useful way of measuring water quality. It’s not rocket science – so we tried it out!

Knowing the water quality in Saffron Brook is important for two reasons. First, it tells us about our local environment and how it is affected by its surroundings. Second, if the Saving the Saffron Brook project makes changes to the Brook, it’s useful to have a measure of what impact any interventions may have had – positive or negative.

Conventional ways of measuring water quality include testing for dissolved oxygen, bacterial counts, or pollutants such as nitrates and phosphates. These measurements are complicated and expensive to carry out, but also, they can change very quickly.  If there is heavy rain for example, any measurements made only a few hours before will be out of date.  For this reason alternative methods of measuring water quality have been developed.  Biotic indices use the aquatic organisms which live in the water to assess the water quality.  Some animals require more oxygen or are less tolerant of pollution than others.  Importantly, they form a record of the conditions over the previous few months so are not just a snapshot of one moment in time like chemical tests. Many different biotic indices have been developed over the years.  Gradually they have become more complex, requiring organisms to be identified with more and more accuracy – something which is difficult to do for larvae of insects.  For this reason, we chose to use one of the older tests, the Trent Biotic Index – it’s the one we will be able to operate reliably with different groups. It was also developed for use in the Trent catchment area.

A selection of the wildlife in the Washbrook – not all of them count in the biotic index!

Two hardy volunteers paddled in the Brook on three sites in Knighton Park, shuffling to dislodge creatures from the stream bed which were then caught in a net.  After that we were able to photograph and identify them. There will be another blog post going into more detail about the different invertebrates we found on our initial survey.

Then came the moment of truth – how clean is the Brook? 

The Trent Biotic Index gives a score from 0 to 10, where zero is basically liquid sewage and 10 is a mountain stream tumbling down a Scottish hillside.  On this scale, we found that the Brook in Knighton Park scores … drumroll … 4/10.  This is probably about what would be expected for a suburban stream.  The big question is – can we improve the water quality?

We’ll need to repeat the sampling several times at different sites because the result can change with the seasons or weather patterns.  Perhaps you can come along and help us next time.  And then we need to see what the score is in one, two or three years time.  Have we saved the Saffron Brook?

Alan Cann, alan.cann@gmail.com